Wine, a beverage enjoyed for centuries, can be a delightful accompaniment to meals, a celebratory drink, or simply a relaxing indulgence. However, like any perishable product, wine can go bad. But what exactly happens if you accidentally, or intentionally, drink wine that has passed its prime? The answer is more nuanced than a simple “you’ll get sick.” It depends on the type of spoilage, the extent of the damage, and your individual sensitivity.
Understanding Wine Spoilage
Wine doesn’t technically “expire” in the way milk does. It doesn’t become unsafe to consume due to bacterial growth in the same manner. Instead, wine undergoes a series of chemical changes over time that can negatively impact its flavor, aroma, and overall quality. These changes are often referred to as spoilage or being “gone bad.”
Common Causes of Wine Spoilage
Several factors can contribute to wine spoilage. Exposure to oxygen, heat, light, and certain microorganisms are the primary culprits.
-
Oxidation: Oxygen is wine’s enemy. While a controlled amount of oxygen is beneficial during the winemaking process, excessive exposure can lead to oxidation. This results in a loss of fruit flavors, browning of the wine (especially in whites), and the development of unpleasant aromas like vinegar or sherry.
-
Heat: High temperatures can accelerate the aging process, causing the wine to become “cooked” and lose its freshness. Wine should ideally be stored at a consistent temperature between 55°F and 65°F (13°C and 18°C).
-
Light: Exposure to ultraviolet (UV) light can damage the wine’s delicate compounds, leading to off-flavors, particularly in lighter-colored wines bottled in clear glass.
-
Microbial Activity: Certain bacteria and yeasts can spoil wine. For example, acetic acid bacteria can convert alcohol into acetic acid, resulting in a vinegary taste. Brettanomyces (Brett) is a yeast that can produce barnyard-like or medicinal aromas.
Identifying Spoiled Wine: Signs to Watch For
Before taking a sip, there are several visual and olfactory clues that can indicate a wine has gone bad.
-
Appearance: Look for changes in color. White wines may turn brownish or golden, while red wines might become brick-red or dull. Sediment is normal in older wines, but excessive cloudiness can be a sign of spoilage.
-
Smell: A spoiled wine might have aromas of vinegar, wet cardboard, nail polish remover (ethyl acetate), or a musty, moldy scent. If the wine smells significantly different from its usual character, it’s a red flag.
-
Taste: If the wine passes the visual and olfactory tests, a small taste can confirm your suspicions. Spoiled wine might taste sour, bitter, or generally unpleasant. It may also lack the vibrancy and complexity it once possessed.
The Potential Effects of Drinking Spoiled Wine
So, what happens if you ignore the warning signs and drink that questionable bottle of wine? Here’s a breakdown of the potential consequences.
Generally Not Harmful, But Unpleasant
In most cases, drinking spoiled wine won’t make you seriously ill. The bacteria and yeasts involved in wine spoilage are usually not pathogenic, meaning they don’t cause disease. However, the taste and aroma will be significantly compromised, leading to an unpleasant drinking experience. The worst-case scenario for most people is a mild stomach upset or a headache.
Vinegar Wine and Acetic Acid
One of the most common forms of wine spoilage is the conversion of alcohol to acetic acid, resulting in a vinegary taste. While vinegar is safe to consume, drinking wine that has turned to vinegar is not enjoyable. The high acidity can also irritate the stomach lining in some individuals.
Brettanomyces and Its Effects
Brettanomyces, often referred to as “Brett,” is a wild yeast that can contaminate wine. While some winemakers consider small amounts of Brett to add complexity, excessive levels can produce undesirable aromas like barnyard, horse sweat, or medicinal notes. While not harmful, these flavors can detract from the wine’s intended character. Some people are more sensitive to Brett than others, experiencing headaches or other adverse reactions.
Sulfite Sensitivity
Sulfites are naturally produced during fermentation and are also added to wine as a preservative. Some individuals are sensitive to sulfites and may experience symptoms like headaches, skin rashes, or breathing difficulties. Spoiled wine may contain higher levels of sulfites due to increased microbial activity, potentially exacerbating these reactions.
Histamine Intolerance
Wine, particularly red wine, contains histamine, a compound that can trigger allergic-like reactions in sensitive individuals. These reactions can include headaches, nasal congestion, skin flushing, and digestive issues. Spoiled wine may contain elevated levels of histamine, potentially worsening these symptoms.
Botulism Risk: A Rare Concern
While extremely rare, there is a theoretical risk of botulism from improperly made or stored wine. Botulism is a serious paralytic illness caused by the bacterium Clostridium botulinum. The high acidity and alcohol content of most wines inhibit the growth of this bacterium, making botulism a very unlikely occurrence. However, in rare cases where wines are made with insufficient acidity or are improperly sealed, the risk cannot be entirely ruled out.
How to Prevent Wine Spoilage
Preventing wine spoilage is crucial to ensure you can enjoy your bottles at their best. Here are some essential tips:
Proper Storage is Key
-
Temperature: Store wine at a consistent temperature between 55°F and 65°F (13°C and 18°C). Avoid drastic temperature fluctuations.
-
Humidity: Maintain a humidity level of around 70% to prevent the cork from drying out and allowing oxygen to enter the bottle.
-
Light: Store wine in a dark place, away from direct sunlight or artificial light.
-
Position: Store bottles horizontally to keep the cork moist.
Sealing Opened Bottles Properly
Once a bottle of wine is opened, it’s important to minimize its exposure to oxygen.
-
Recork Immediately: Replace the cork as soon as possible after pouring.
-
Use a Wine Preserver: Consider using a wine preserver, such as a vacuum pump or an inert gas spray, to remove oxygen from the bottle.
-
Refrigerate: Store opened bottles of wine in the refrigerator to slow down the oxidation process.
Knowing When to Drink Your Wine
Not all wines are meant to be aged. Most wines are intended to be consumed within a few years of their vintage date. Research the specific wine you have to determine its optimal drinking window. Drinking a wine past its prime won’t hurt you, but the flavor will likely be diminished.
When to Consult a Doctor
While drinking spoiled wine is generally not harmful, there are certain situations where you should seek medical attention.
-
Severe Symptoms: If you experience severe symptoms such as difficulty breathing, muscle weakness, or paralysis, seek immediate medical attention. These could be signs of botulism, although extremely unlikely.
-
Persistent Symptoms: If you experience persistent nausea, vomiting, or diarrhea after drinking spoiled wine, consult a doctor.
-
Underlying Health Conditions: If you have underlying health conditions, such as a compromised immune system, consult a doctor if you experience any adverse reactions after drinking spoiled wine.
In Conclusion
Drinking wine that has gone bad is usually more of a sensory disappointment than a health hazard. While the unpleasant taste and aroma can ruin your enjoyment, the risk of serious illness is low. By understanding the causes of wine spoilage, learning to identify the signs, and following proper storage and preservation techniques, you can minimize the chances of encountering spoiled wine and ensure a pleasurable drinking experience. Remember, when in doubt, throw it out! It’s always better to err on the side of caution and discard a bottle of wine that you suspect has gone bad. Your palate (and your stomach) will thank you.
FAQ 1: How can I tell if my wine has gone bad?
Identifying spoiled wine involves assessing its appearance, smell, and taste. Look for changes in color, such as a brownish tint in red wine or a deep golden hue in white wine. Observe if there’s excessive sediment or cloudiness, which can indicate spoilage. A visual inspection is the first crucial step to ensure your wine is still palatable.
The next step involves assessing the aroma. Common signs of spoiled wine include a vinegary or burnt sugar smell, a musty or moldy odor, or a wet cardboard scent. Trust your nose; if the aroma is off-putting, the wine likely is. Similarly, a lack of fruit character or an overly bitter taste are strong indicators of deterioration. A combination of visual and olfactory cues offers a reliable gauge of wine quality.
FAQ 2: What are the potential health risks of drinking spoiled wine?
The primary concern with drinking spoiled wine isn’t necessarily a risk of severe illness, but rather an unpleasant experience and potential minor digestive upset. Spoiled wine, due to oxidation or bacterial contamination, can have off-putting flavors and aromas. While not typically toxic, the presence of excessive acetic acid (vinegar) or other byproducts of microbial activity can irritate the stomach lining.
In rare cases, if the wine is contaminated with harmful bacteria like Acetobacter, it could lead to temporary gastrointestinal discomfort, such as nausea or diarrhea. However, the alcohol content in wine usually inhibits the growth of dangerous pathogens. Overall, while drinking spoiled wine isn’t recommended, it’s unlikely to cause serious health problems, more often resulting in an unpleasant taste experience.
FAQ 3: Does wine always turn into vinegar when it goes bad?
While wine can turn into vinegar if exposed to air and certain bacteria, it’s not the only way wine spoils. The process of wine turning into vinegar is due to the activity of Acetobacter bacteria, which convert ethanol (alcohol) into acetic acid (vinegar). This process requires oxygen, so it’s more likely to happen in partially filled bottles or wines that aren’t properly sealed.
Other forms of spoilage can occur, such as oxidation (leading to a flat, sherry-like flavor), refermentation (resulting in bubbles in a still wine), or the presence of unwanted microbial growth (like Brettanomyces, which can cause barnyard-like aromas). Therefore, while vinegar formation is a possible outcome, it’s not the sole indicator of spoiled wine; other flavor and aroma changes can also signal deterioration.
FAQ 4: How can I prevent my wine from going bad after opening a bottle?
Minimizing oxygen exposure is the key to preventing opened wine from spoiling quickly. Re-corking the bottle immediately after pouring is the simplest method. Storing the bottle upright reduces the surface area exposed to air. Using a wine stopper or a vacuum pump to remove air from the bottle further slows down the oxidation process.
Refrigeration also plays a crucial role in preserving opened wine. Lower temperatures slow down chemical reactions, including oxidation. Even red wines benefit from being stored in the refrigerator after opening; just remember to let them warm up slightly before serving. By combining these techniques, you can significantly extend the lifespan of your opened wine.
FAQ 5: How long does wine typically last after opening?
The lifespan of an opened wine bottle varies depending on the type of wine and how it’s stored. Generally, red wines can last 3-5 days after opening if properly re-corked and stored in a cool, dark place. White and rosé wines tend to last slightly less, around 2-3 days, due to their lower tannin content and increased susceptibility to oxidation.
Sparkling wines are the most delicate and lose their bubbles quickly after opening, typically lasting only 1-3 days even with a sparkling wine stopper. Fortified wines, like Port or Sherry, have a longer shelf life due to their higher alcohol content, often lasting several weeks if properly sealed and stored. These are general guidelines, and taste is the best indicator; trust your senses to determine if the wine is still enjoyable.
FAQ 6: Can all types of wine go bad, or are some more resistant to spoilage?
Yes, all types of wine can eventually spoil, but certain characteristics make some wines more resistant to spoilage than others. Wines with higher acidity, tannin levels, or alcohol content tend to have a longer shelf life. Tannins, found predominantly in red wines, act as natural preservatives, slowing down oxidation and microbial activity.
Similarly, higher alcohol content inhibits the growth of spoilage microorganisms. Sweet wines with residual sugar are also more prone to spoilage if not properly stored, as the sugar can provide a food source for unwanted yeast or bacteria. The overall quality of the wine and how it was made also influence its longevity. Higher-quality wines often possess better structure and balance, making them more resilient to degradation.
FAQ 7: Can I use spoiled wine for cooking?
Using spoiled wine for cooking is generally not recommended, especially if the wine has a strong vinegary or otherwise unpleasant aroma. Cooking can mask some off-flavors, but it won’t eliminate them entirely. The spoiled wine can impart undesirable tastes to your dish, potentially ruining the overall flavor profile.
However, if the wine is only slightly oxidized (lacking fresh fruit character but not exhibiting distinct spoilage aromas) and you’re using it in a dish with strong flavors, it might be acceptable in a pinch. For example, a slightly oxidized red wine might be used in a long-simmering stew. Always prioritize using fresh, good-quality wine for the best cooking results. When in doubt, discard the spoiled wine and use a fresh bottle, or substitute with broth or another appropriate liquid.